Our research is editorially independent but we may earn a commission for purchases made through our links.
Key West, Florida is a popular vacation spot with a number of incredible restaurants to keep both tourists and locals happy. From seafood joints to Cuban eateries, Key West is teeming with mouthwatering cuisine. Arrive hungry at these best restaurants in Key West, Florida.
Blue Heaven
Blue Heaven has made a name for itself in Key West due to its delicious eats and live music. From seasonal seafood dishes to American, Mediterranean and Caribbean cuisine, this Key West eatery offers a variety of dishes that please different taste buds. When the weather is right, enjoy the outdoor dining area with its shady palm trees and outdoor stage. Blue Heaven serves up great food for breakfast, lunch and dinner. The lobster Benedict is a must for brunch, while the jerk chicken and barbecue shrimp are popular dinner eats. However, you don’t want to leave Blue Heaven without trying one of the best key lime pies in the Florida Keys.
Latitudes
Found on the small island of Sunset Key, Latitudes offers an upscale dining experience for those wanting to dine with a view of the gulf or even eat right on the beach. To access this restaurant, you’ll have to take a shuttle ferry; this restaurant is part of Sunset Key Cottages, a Key West resort. Expect fresh seafood on the menu here, from Florida spiny lobster to grilled fish. Guests tired of seafood can also indulge in braised short rib, grilled chicken, and steak dishes. Although a sunset dinner here is bound to be unforgettable, Latitudes also serves breakfast and lunch as well.
El Siboney
Florida is known for its delicious Cuban restaurants, but if you’re in Key West, look no further than El Siboney. This Cuban joint is a popular hangout spot for tourists and locals tonight, so expect a busy restaurant no matter what day you visit. On the menu here, you’ll find Cuban classics and traditional dishes. There is a variety of options on El Siboney’s menu, with numerous dishes made with chicken, pork, beef and seafood. You will leave here feeling full and satisfied, as before your meal arrives you’ll be served a fresh batch of Cuban bread. And the flan is so creamy here you won’t want to say no to this dessert dish.
Hogfish Bar and Grill
This casual eatery on the docks is where the locals go to enjoy a cold drink and great food. Hogfish Bar and Grill is off the beaten path, but well worth the journey. Found on Stock Island, you’ll want to order the hogfish sandwich, made with none other than local hogfish. This bar and grill give off a true Key West vibe with its open-air dining and great happy hour options.
B.O.’s Fish Wagon
If you want to dine in at a no-fuss establishment while in Key West, then visit B.O.’s Fish Wagon. This open-air restaurant and bar opened as a makeshift food truck in the 70s but still stands as an iconic fixture in the Key West food scene. You’ll find one of the best fried fish sandwiches in the Key West area here. Music lovers should visit on Friday nights, where late-night live tunes are a regular occurrence at B.O.’s.
Santiago’s Bodega
Experience the flavors of the Iberian peninsula right here in Key West when you dine at Santiago’s Bodega. Since this restaurant is located in Bahama Village, this eatery is a great spot to stop after exploring the top attractions in Key West, specifically after visiting the Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum, which is just a short walk away. The menu here is full of Spanish tapas and wine, so you may want to sit and stay awhile at Santiago’s Bodega.
7305, 207 Petronia St #101, Key West, FL 33040, USA— +1 305-296-7691
Conch Republic Seafood Company
Found on Key West’s historic seaport, Conch Republic Seafood Company is a go-to spot for happy hour and live music here in Key West. Seafood is what you’ll want to order here, especially the conch fritters, tempura-batter cracked conch, or conch chowder. With a name like Conch Republic Seafood Company, you’ll want to try their conch dishes while you’re here. However, the two-for-one drink specials during happy hour pair nicely with whatever dish you order, conch or not.
Hot Tin Roof
Part of the Ocean Key Resort & Spa, Hot Tin Roof treats diners with a breathtaking view of Key West Harbor that offers a great spot to catch a Florida sunset. Perfect for date night, Hot Tin Roof serves up shareable tapas dishes along with traditional entrees too. From grouper to lobster to steak, the menu here is sure to please. The Latin-inspired dishes are always a good choice here, but no matter what you choose, you shouldn’t skimp out on the key lime pie.
Nine One Five
Nine One Five operates out of an 1850s Victorian mansion. This elegant establishment serves American dishes that pair well with its extensive wine list. This upscale eatery offers a great dinner spot that is found along Duval Street. Nine One Five isn’t just ideal for dinner but also a hot spot for drinks at its upstairs lounge, Point 5. Expect well-made seafood options on the menu at Nine One Five, from the chef’s ceviche appetizer to the yellowtail snapper entree.
The Thirsty Mermaid
If you’re craving oysters in Key West, then you’ll want to visit The Thirsty Mermaid. This oyster bar offers oysters from both the east and west coast, depending on the day. Although it would be a shame to pass up the oysters here, there are plenty of great seafood entrees to keep you happy. You’ll find caviar, lobster, tuna, conch and even steak on the menu at The Thirsty Mermaid. As the name implies, you’ll want to come thirsty, as this restaurant has a wide variety of craft beers and wines too.
